MINUTES OF THE
SENATE COMMITTEE ON COMMERCE AND LABOR
Sixty-ninth Session
May 1, 1997
The Senate Committee on Commerce and Labor was called to order by Chairman Randolph J. Townsend, at 8:00 a.m., on Thursday, May 1, 1997, in Room 2135 of the Legislative Building, Carson City, Nevada. Exhibit A is the Agenda. Exhibit B is the Attendance Roster.
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT:
Senator Randolph J. Townsend, Chairman
Senator Ann O’Connell, Vice Chairman
Senator Kathy Augustine
Senator Dean A. Rhoads
Senator Joseph M. Neal, Jr.
Senator Raymond C. Shaffer
Senator Michael A. (Mike) Schneider
STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT:
Scott Young, Committee Policy Analyst
Carolyn Hoganson, Committee Secretary
OTHERS PRESENT:
Jerry Higgins, Lobbyist, Nevada State Board of Professional Engineers and Land Surveyors
William R. Petty, P.E., Chairman, State Board of Professional Engineers and Land Surveyors
Phil M. Herrington, Chief Building Official, City of Carson City
Dale A. R. Erquiaga, Chief Deputy Secretary of State, Office of the Secretary of State
Anne B. Cathcart, Senior Deputy Attorney General, Litigation Division, Office of the Attorney General
Douglas E. Walther, Senior Deputy Attorney General, Commerce Section, Civil Division, Office of the Attorney General
Robert Kramer, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas
Frank LaConte, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas
Pat Coward, Lobbyist, Nevada Association of Realtors
Ralph Thomas, Concerned Citizen, Reno
Judi Root, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas
Jean Georges, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas
Robert Lyle, Concerned Citizen, Reno
Jim Linebaugh, Concerned Citizen, Reno
Jeanne Mullich, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas
Sherrell Willey, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas
Irene E. Porter, Lobbyist, Southern Nevada Home Builders Association
Sharron Skroch, Concerned Citizen, Reno
Vincent Ragazzo, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas
Dennis McGarvey, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas
Eseissa C. Lavelle, Concerned Citizen
Joan C. Wright, Lobbyist, Carriage House Timeshare and Silver Oak Development
Jack Straus, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas
Gary Lein, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas
Chairman Townsend opened the hearing with the work session on Senate Bill (S.B.) 306 and S.B. 307. Senator Townsend remarked this meeting was videoconferenced from Room 4412 of the Grant Sawyer State Office Building, Las Vegas, Nevada.
senate bill 306: Provides for administrative review of disciplinary action against real estate licensee upon discovery of new evidence. (BDR 54-1132)
senate bill 307: Makes various changes to provisions governing Oriental medicine. (BDR 54-1242)
There was no discussion on these bills at this time and Senator Townsend closed the work session.
Senator Townsend opened the hearing on Assembly Bill 328.
assembly bill 328: Requires certain governmental entities to notify state board of professional engineers and land surveyors concerning certain incomplete or rejected plans. (BDR 54-1203)
Jerry Higgins, Lobbyist, Nevada State Board of Professional Engineers and Land Surveyors, introduced Bill Petty and Phil Herrington who were there to testify on A.B. 328. William R. Petty, P.E., Chairman, State Board of Professional Engineers and Land Surveyors, stated plans are received by the building department and reviewed. These plans were checked by registered people and after the third time of being checked and the design was not corrected properly, the state board was informed. The board would then make a review to determine what the problem was or if it affected the public. The purpose of the bill expands on building officials bringing the matter to the board’s attention so the plans could be reviewed. Mr. Petty handed out a copy of the Nevada Administrative Code 625.550 (Exhibit C).
Senator O'Connell asked if there had been a multitude of problems which brought this bill forward or was it something the board found where there was a loophole that needed to be closed. Mr. Petty stated there were problems and, as plans become more complex, what had been happening was a reluctance to bring the plans to the board’s attention. This bill allowed the board to find out what problems were in the field. Mr. Higgins explained most of the building officials in the state were not registered engineers or land surveyors and they did not have the umbrella of the law to tell engineers and surveyors they had to notify the board if they continued to submit incomplete or incompetent work.
Senator Townsend noted the board was asking the local government to become a policing agency and was that why there is a fiscal note on this bill. Phil M. Herrington, Chief Building Official, City of Carson City, surmised he did not think there was that much of an impact on local government because the plans were in the public’s sphere, and they would notify the state board of engineers if they had some comments on a project and they would do the footwork. Senator Townsend asked if he had come across any inappropriate documents. Mr. Herrington replied there had been a few and there is some reluctance on a non-registered professional engineer bringing something before the board. If we can relate to state law that it is required by the state then that gives us a lot of support.
Senator Neal commented as he understood this bill you would only be required to submit the plans if they were substantially incomplete or if submitted plans were rejected by the department at least three times. Mr. Herrington stated that was correct. Senator Neal queried what was a substantially incomplete plan, and Mr. Herrington answered it was when the mechanics of engineering or the life-safety issues of the building code was being violated. Senator Neal inquired if other groups could submit plans. Mr. Herrington pointed out any individual could submit plans to a jurisdiction depending on what type of project it was. Senator Neal stated by listing the professional engineer and land surveyor it suggested that no one else could submit those plans, and if that was the intent. Mr. Petty replied "no", they were concerned with the statutes for the engineering board and land survey board, the architects have their statutes. One of the problems was the fact there were several ways plans can be submitted, but they are only concerned about the engineers. They have an enforcement arm that tries to make sure that the public is being protected with the plans the engineers are submitting. The incomplete plans with the building increase in southern Nevada, there is an urgency to get plans to the building officials before they are complete. The problem was unless there were checked, a project can go through the construction process with improper documents. Senator Neal asked if these plans referenced here were to buildings. Mr. Petty replied primarily construction-type projects were the big problem.
Mr. Herrington expanded on Senator Neal’s question by stating with jurisdiction a building official could take matters before the state board of architecture, state board of contractors, and state board of engineers, if those plans were deficit the building official could request a review by any one of three entities. This bill provides support for the building official, who is a non-registered professional engineer, to do that because there is some political impact to taking matters before the board. This bill would require building officials to bring professional engineers before the professional engineering board.
Senator Shaffer pointed out that it was not a common practice as the plans checker would be the first to go to the building official and say there was someone who was constantly submitting plans that were deficit and the plans checker would not be able to complete the check. At that time, the building official would bring it to the attention of the individual a couple of times. This bill would make it very simple by saying this is the law.
senator neal moved to do pass A.B. 328.
Senator O’Connell seconded the motion.
the motion carried unanimously.
* * * * *
Senator Townsend announced S.B. 299 would be rescheduled as requested by Senator Titus.
Senator Townsend opened the hearing on S.B. 314.
senate bill 314: Revises provisions governing unit-owners’ associations. (BDR 10-1380)
Senator Michael A. Schneider, Clark County Senatorial District No. 8, testified in support of S.B. 314 and stated last session he was successful in having a bill on alternative dispute resolution for homeowner’s associations. That bill had been a very good bill by helping to resolve disputes with arbitration. He referred to copies of newspaper articles (Exhibit D) which compared homeowners’ associations to private clubs. He stated homeowners associations were not operated that way because of the major investment in an association, individuals do not freely move in and out of these associations. The government had regulated mortgage companies, banks, realtors and all professionals dealing with real estate, homeowner associations were not regulated. He felt it was time these associations were operated as a business or more open, like government. There was a consensus from all professional organizations that homeowner associations needed improvement.
Senator Schneider referred to a copy of a lawsuit, Glenbrook Homeowners Association v Mr. & Mrs. Petititt (Exhibit E), stating this was a decision by the Nevada Supreme Court which stated that homeowner’s associations could execute eminent domain over members in their association. Senator Townsend stated the copy of the lawsuit should be sent to the Senate Committee on Judiciary for review.
Senator Schneider stated there was no homestead clause in the associations, which meant a member of an association could be fined, the associations could lien their property, and within 30 days go into foreclosure. There was no due process on that, which was needed, as mortgage companies were regulated, and had to go through a time period of due process before they would be able to take property. Many of these associations do not have regular scheduled meetings and they fail to issue financial statements on a regular basis. A lot of associations were in severe financial trouble, and people do not know this information when they buy a home in an association and could accrue a deferred maintenance of a substantial amount of money.
Dale A. R. Erquiaga, Chief Deputy Secretary of State, Office of the Secretary of State, commented homeowners’ associations were incorporated as nonprofit. The homeowners’ associations were one of the top complaints received in their office, complaints of no access to financial statements, improperly run meetings, and questions about the bylaws. The secretary of state is a ministerial office, they file articles and annual lists, they do not file bylaws or financial information, and they do not have the information members of the associations want.
Anne B. Cathcart, Senior Deputy Attorney General, Litigation Division, Office of the Attorney General, stated S.B. 314 amends chapter 116 of the Nevada Revised Statutes (NRS) in order to strengthen state laws regarding homeowners’ associations. The intent of the bill was primarily to reduce problems, confusion, lack of education, lack of remedies among association owners, board members and property managers. She referred to the proposed amendments to S.B. 314 dated April 28, 1997 (Exhibit F) which was distributed to the committee and faxed to Las Vegas. The attorney general’s office supported Senator Schneider’s efforts to improve the homeowner associations laws.
Douglas E. Walther, Senior Deputy Attorney General, Commerce Section, Civil Division, Office of the Attorney General, referred to Amendments to S.B. 314 - Unit Owner’s Associations (Exhibit G) which was proposed by the attorney general’s office. He had a handout of how to handle problems with a co-op’s Board of Directors Questions and Answers prepared by New York State Department of Law (Exhibit H).
Senator Townsend asked Mr. Walther to explain each amendment and the intent.
Mr. Walther explained:
Amendment 1 deletes section 1 of the original bill which provided for the assessment of a fee by the attorney general to establish a regulatory program for homeowners’ association, and is consistent with our intent to attempt to reduce the fiscal impact of the bill.
Amendment 2 amends section 2 of the bill to conform to the deletion of the assessment part and to clarify the applicability section so the new sections being proposed in the amendments will apply as the other amendments in the existing bill will apply.
Amendment 3 amends section 4 of the original bill, which is on page 3, line 18 and the amendment amends the new language in the original bill which starts at line 32 through 36, and this language requires the new members of an executive board to obtain education. The original bill required education to be courses approved by the attorney general, we have amended that to provide for the real estate commission to review those proposed courses. They have a lot of expertise and experience with continuing education requirements for real estate licensees and we think they are better suited to perform that task. It also clarifies that the education is to be obtained at the association’s expense. It contains minimum and maximum hours for the education and otherwise leaves the education requirement intact as proposed in the original bill.
Amendment 4 amends section 5, line 37 of page 3 and goes to page 4, this amendment eliminates the authority of the attorney general to specify restrictions in association bylaws. The intent of this language was to strengthen rights of home owners to participate in the associations, rather than approach it from an active involvement of our office in specifying items that need to be in bylaws or reviewing proposed changes in bylaws. Our preferred approach would be to look at the provisions that are in the law now that override or govern operations of the associations and see if we can make those clearer and provide more opportunity for involvement of home owners and put those things in the law rather than have us review them on a case-by-case basis or working into some kind of regulatory process in that situation.
Amendment 5 amends section 6 of the original bill which starts on page 4, line 21 and the purpose of this amendment we are proposing is to increase the opportunity for members to participate in association meetings. The original bill required association meetings be held once each month. In my review of other states’ laws that seemed to be too frequent and I looked at the varieties of ways laws were coming out on the frequency of meetings and it seemed that a fairly frequent interval, but not too frequent to be unworkable or discourage participation was quarterly. So we have suggested that frequency requirement be amended to having a meeting once every 90 days. I also looked at other states’ laws regarding the percentage of members required to call a special meeting. That is the type of problem we have heard a lot of at the attorney general’s office from people calling with various problems about their homeowners’ associations. We tell them it works like a democracy and you have to participate in the process. Their complaint is that the numbers required in order for them to get some consensus together to get an issue before the board is so high that they have difficulty doing that. We are proposing that the percentage required of members to call on their own a special meeting be reduced from 20 percent to 10 percent of the voting members interested in order to call the meetings to get whatever item they want on the agenda for an association or executive- board meeting. We are also proposing that the law be clarified that members who are attending association meetings and meetings of the executive board have the right to attend, listen and speak. Reviewing our existing law that is not specifically stated. It is probably covered in most bylaws but it is not provided for in law. We are also clarifying what types of issues should the executive board meet in a closed session, as we have had complaints on that from people attending meetings and the board has gone into a closed session and they wonder what the authority is for them to do that. In the proposed amendment they can close a meeting to meet with their attorney to discuss something that would be covered by the attorney/client privilege in pending litigation against the association or to discuss personnel matters in the management of the association.
Senator Neal queried how the determination was made with regard to the closed meetings. Mr. Walther explained when there was litigation against the association and those matters were discussed in an open meeting the opportunity for information which should be kept confidential might hurt the association’s litigation efforts. Senator Neal asked "to keep it confidential from the home owners". Mr. Walther stated, for the intent, there was an opportunity for that information to go beyond the home owners to the opposing side in the lawsuit to hear the discussion of attorney-client communications regarding your strategy in the case. These were provisions in other state laws that had been reviewed.
Senator Neal inquired as to the personnel matters. Mr. Walther replied personnel was a similar situation as this would be sensitive and confidential information which invokes the privacy interests of the individuals involved, especially of hiring and firing decisions based on private information of the individual.
Mr. Walther continued with the explanations of the amendments:
Finally, this particular amendment makes it clear that when a home owner attends a meeting they are allowed to speak and in conjunction with an existing amendment, it requires there be an agenda of an association meeting and for there to be on every agenda a portion for member comment. To make it clear, when a member shows up at a meeting they have the right to get up and speak at the portion of the meeting devoted to hearing members’ comments. Again, that is the thing that they had heard of at our office, that people show up to the meetings and they are either denied, they feel they are not welcome to speak or bring up new issues. We want to encourage that and make it clear that they have that right.
The next amendment which is amendment 6, this amendment deletes section 9 of the bill which is on page 7, line 24 of the original bill. These are the provisions that provide, in conjunction with the assessment process, for the attorney general to employ a regulation or enforcement unit to monitor the activities of homeowners’ associations and review complaints, and conduct investigations. If we are trying to eliminate the fiscal impact and make the bill more workable in that regard we obviously have to eliminate the provisions to the bill that create the fiscal impact and those are found in section 9. I should add we are not trying to divorce ourselves from this process completely. What we are trying to do is do so in a more workable manner, we are ready to work with the Real Estate Division and Real Estate Commission in dealing with the issues of education of board members. There is another part of the amendments that I will get to that deals with the creation of a disclosure form so that prospective purchasers of the associations can have the critical elements of what they are going to get into if they purchase into a common-interest community highlighted to them. We will work in developing that form and are also ready to work in a more general type of education effort to work directly with associations and executive boards to educate both the boards and the members on the requirements of the law and try to through that means encourage greater participation and a greater level of confidence in the management of the associations.
Amendment 7 which is adding a new section to the bill, this section requires the Real Estate Division to develop a form that would be provided to prospective purchasers in a unit of common- interest community as well as prospective purchasers of a resale unit in a common-interest community. The idea is to recognize that most of these documents that relate to these communities’ Convenants, Conditions and Restrictions (CC&R), bylaws, financial statement and other documents are now provided to prospective owners either in the public offering statement or they are required to be provided to prospective purchasers on a resale. However, these documents are voluminous and people considering such a purchase do not take the time to wade through these voluminous documents that are written in legalese and take the time to understand some of the critical features of this type of living. The purpose of this new section is to require the development of a form that will highlight or bring out in a generic way, in a way that applies to all community-interest communities, the types of things or issues that you would be concerned with if you were purchasing a unit. Such as the financial obligation that you are committing to pay for an indefinite period of assessments to upkeep the common elements.
Senator O'Connell called attention to it being helpful to the members if they had a copy of minutes of past meetings. Then the members would have a very clear understanding of what the problems were with the association as compared to legal documents. She asked if Mr. Walther, in his research with other states, had found the associations giving those minutes to the prospective buyers. Mr. Walther replied he had not found that, but a lot of the other states’, laws do specifically mention minutes among the records that needed to be made available to members and did not think it would present a problem.
Mr. Walther explained more of the amendments:
In another section of our proposed amendment they are clarifying a statute with regard to record keeping and making it clear that minutes including some generalized minutes of closed sessions of the executive board be maintained by the association and be made available to members upon request. The idea of the form would be to hopefully encourage people to read it. If it is one page it will not take that long to read and will cover the key points you would encounter. The possibility that if you do not pay your assessments there could be a lien put on it and you could lose the unit to foreclosure. The fact that your lifestyle is going to be restricted somewhat. There are rules and regulations that you are going to be bound by and if you want to see what particular rules and regulations are in this community you should check them out before you make the decision to purchase. Those types of things that are going to apply in every community associations just to highlight and encourage people to investigate the purchase a little more and hopefully educate them and make it easier for them to educate themselves so they make an informed purchase.
Amendment 8 amends an existing statute but not one that is covered in the original bill. This amends Nevada Revised Statues (NRS) 116.4103 which deals with public-offering statements for prospective purchasers and common-interest communities. It amends that section so that the disclosure form to which he just referred is among those items that is provided to prospective purchasers. It also amends the public-offering statement requirement to include a specific section regarding the amount that is set aside as a reserve for repairs and replacements of common elements, which is another area that the bill addresses.
Amendment 9 amends NRS 116.4109 which again is not in the original bill but that section in the existing law deals with what documents are required to be shown to a prospective purchaser on a resale of the unit in a common-interest community. Again that tracks the form we are suggesting be required, so that a person reselling a unit will provide the form that will be developed by the Real Estate Division and also specify the amounts set aside for reserves and disclose the existence of any pending litigation against the association.
Amendment 10 amends NRS 116.3118 which is the statute regarding financial records of associations. Basically deletes that entire section and adds a lot of new language which is much more specific about the requirements for record keeping in associations. It specifies the documents that need to be maintained at the office of the association. Those records include the copy of the bylaws, the articles of incorporation, the CC&Rs, any plans, specifications or permits relating to the improvements in the project, a current roster of owners and financial-accounting records for expenditures on the common elements. It also specifies that those documents be maintained at a location in this state and provides some detailed provisions regarding member’s access to that information. It provides that the board can require the member to pay the actual costs of copying the documents and that should address the problem of discouraging access to records by charging exorbitant fees for gaining access. It also specifies what types of records may be withheld from the membership and again that tracks the provisions in the meetings regarding closed executive sessions. Things relating to personal-private matters like medical records and things relating to pending litigation.
Senator Augustine asked why would it be permissive to withhold someone’s personal medical records, should that be mandatory. Mr. Walther stated he thought it was a good idea to make it mandatory.
Mr. Walther continued:
Amendment 11, this is adding a new section to the law which specifies and clarifies provisions regarding the adoption of rules at common interest communities by the associations. This clarifies what was probably already in the CC&Rs or bylaws regarding people’s obligation to comply with those rules and make it clear to apply to members and people that are there with the consent of the members, like attendants, guests, or invitees as well as members of the executive board. They are bound by the rules to govern their conduct as well. Provides provisions that state the rules need to be reasonably related to the purpose of which they were adopted. They need to be specific enough so that a member knows what type of conduct is being prohibited or required. They need to be adopted in good faith and not for the purpose of abating any other obligation of the association arising under the community documents or the statutes. They have to be consistent with the CC&Rs, the bylaws; those are the documents that grant the authority to opt the rules, so like regulations they cannot go beyond those things or be inconsistent with any of those provisions. Provides some details on limits to what the association can do for a violation of rules, limits on the amount of the fine, and provision that if you are going to suspend any member’s privileges in a common-interest community for violation of rules, you can’t prevent them from getting in and out of their unit.
Amendment 12 adds a new section to the law which deals with the hiring process of the professional managers of the associations. This was a provision that was in the California law, it basically sets forth requirements for a prospective managing agent to provide information about their qualifications and experience to the board of the association before they are hired as a professional manager. If they have any professional licensees or designations, they are required to disclose those. If they have had any professional disciplinary problems, licensing problems, they are to disclose that. Basically it is a resume requirement for a professional manager so that the board of directors can make a more informed decision about hiring a professional managing agent.
Amendment 13 adds a definition to chapter 116 [of NRS] for governing documents which includes the declaration and other bylaws, operating rules, articles of incorporation, and other legal documents that govern the makeup of the community association.
Amendment 14 which is the final amendment adds a new section to chapter 116 of NRS which deals with the obligation of the board of directors to review the financial performance of the association and it sets the minimal requirements for the board to be reviewing on a regular basis the operating accounts of the association, to look at the monthly statements, to get a reconciliation of the account, to look at the reserve accounts and look at the bank monthly statements so they can stay on top of the association’s financial performance. I’m sure a lot of this is being done currently but this is to make it clear that this is an obligation of the board of directors to see what the financial condition is of the association. It requires at least two signatures of members of the executive board or one member who is not a member of the executive board, plus a member on the board should be required to withdraw any funds from the reserve account for replacement or repair of items in the common elements. It also requires that the board at least once every 3 years conduct a study of the reserve requirements to repair elements of the common elements of which the board or association is responsible, such as roofs, common-private roadways, air-conditioning units, things which are the obligation of the association to repair or to replace or maintain. The purpose of the study is to retain an estimate of the remaining usual life of these items and come up with an estimate of the amount of the reserves that would be required to replace that item when its useful life is up and it needs replacing. The purpose there is to keep the reserves maintained by the association on track and current with current prices and conditions of the common elements in the association.
Senator Augustine remarked that Mr. Walther had been talking about an executive board throughout the amendment, and was this executive board consisting of home owners in that association, because those mandates seemed to be excessive for someone who was volunteering their time to participate in their association. Mr. Walther answered the executive board were home owners who were volunteering their time. It was the intent of the amendments to create obligations on part of the association and to highlight them so the management of the association knew these were obligations and they are required. There was nothing in the amendment that precluded a board of directors to delegate those duties to a professional manager or to hire professional help.
Senator Augustine queried about amendment 14, page 10 of Exhibit G, which talked about a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection, who would decide this. Mr. Walther said the common-sense application of those words and to do the best to inspect the common elements, technically each member of the association would have the right to enforce the language or go to arbitration and bring the dispute to the meeting of the association.
Senator Neal noticed that the attorney general’s office had excised themselves from the law by this amendment and had offered rules and regulations to reach a problem where there might be violations and he questioned what the penalties would be. Mr. Walther responded the existing law was associations were governed by their members to enforce rules and documents that govern their conduct. The attorney general’s office had looked at other states’ laws for the purpose of determining whether the other states were involving their attorney general’s office or any other state agency in the regulation of the day-to-day affairs of the associations, but we could not find any. The intent of these amendments were to clarify what the rights of the members were and to increase the self-help of the members.
Ms. Cathcart stated one thing their office had noted when contacting other states’ attorney general offices were involvement in dealing with grievances of homeowners’ associations were very staff intensive. It was the belief of their staff that there were other ways to accomplish the objective without massive increases in state employees, support staff and equipment. The attorney general’s office felt that education was most important and our office would work with industry members and the real estate commissioner in developing a booklet that could be given to all association members and perspective members that would give them an understanding of the state laws and their rights. This was in addition to the disclosure in the public offering or upon resale. This would be a better way to accomplish that objective.
Senator Neal stated what he had heard in the testimony was there were associations and some members of the associations had taken certain rules and authority to themselves, and he questioned how this situation would be handled. Ms. Cathcart stated the attorney general’s office would be willing to work on penalties for violations.
Senator Shaffer stated he felt there should be penalties as there were problems in these associations with people taking over the association and controlling the meetings, and if this statute were going to be enforced there would need to be penalties.
Mr. Walther stated they would look at the issue of penalties and the attorney general’s office was trying to increase the opportunity for members who felt they do not have a say in the association meetings to be able to exercise their rights and take issues of the abuses.
Robert Kramer, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas, testified in support of S.B. 314. He expressed his concerns of the association of which he was a home owner and the meetings of where the members were not allowed to speak and had no financial statements. He stated their association needed help and felt that S.B. 314 could solve all their problems.
Frank LaConte, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas, testified he resided in Summerlin, was a home owner and would be interested in attending the subcommittee because of all these amendments.
Pat Coward, Lobbyist, Nevada Association of Realtors, stated they would like to participate in the subcommittees, as this was a complicated issue.
Ralph Thomas, Concerned Citizen, Reno, presented a copy of his testimony and read from prepared text (Exhibit I). He voiced his concerns on S.B. 314 and felt that some interpretation was needed to define the term "Association". He stressed his concerns on the fees to be paid to the attorney general’s office for each unit governed by the association. Senator Schneider emphasized in the bill the fee referred to was based on there being approximately 30,000 units in this state and the fee would be $3 to $5 per year.
Judi Root, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas, testified and stated her opinions for the bill. She felt if all the neighbors in an association would treat each other like human beings, their problems would be solved.
Jean Georges, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas, stated she had looked at this bill from four perspectives, first as mediator, home owner and a board member. She was opposed to this bill and voiced her concerns about the manner in how these issues were being addressed and stated her concerns about the amendments.
Robert Lyle, Concerned Citizen, Reno, commented he was for and against the bill. As an overview there appeared to be problems in some areas on some boards with regard to the rights which were provided for pursuant to the documents that existed. It appeared the intent of the legislation was to make universal conduct which was going on with the boards. The legislation seeks to assess all homeowners’ associations to pay for those associations that are having the problems. His concerns were with the fee to be assessed. Perhaps the legislation could have some kind of code of conduct with penalties so the code of conduct was uniform. It had been difficult to find members to serve on the boards and if a substantial education requirement was added that could lead to further difficulties. Someone would have to pay for this education and that would eventually have to be passed on to the home owners.
Senator Neal asked Mr. Lyle, since he had experience, if he could give a reason as to the problems that seemed to arise with these boards. Mr. Lyle answered he had never experienced these problems with any board, but it appeared to him what seemed to cause the problem was that people abuse the power by virtue that they have been elected. Then it is very difficult to get enough votes to remove that person from the board.
Senator O’Connell gave an example of a complaint that she had received recently where a home owner had a solar system installed on her roof and another tenant complained to the board. The home owner was told to remove this solar system and a lien was put on her condominium. When talking to the board members they would not back away from this incident.
Senator Schneider stated Mr. Lyle mentioned the classes on the education, if this was arranged for a Saturday morning for 4 hours, would this be too much to ask a board member to attend so they could go over the rules and regulations of the association. Mr. Lyle replied with his experience most boards had difficulty to get responsible people to take the time, if this would be part of the board meeting they would probably attend for the education.
Jim Linebaugh, Concerned Citizen, Reno, stated he was a member of the Sierra Cedars Homeowners’ Association. He commented he had come to oppose the bill but after hearing the amendments from the attorney general’s office he was impressed and thought it could be put into a bill that could help the homeowners’ association. His concerns would be about the training and the costs. He felt progress was being made, with the subcommittee meetings and the work of the attorney general’s office this could turn out to be very good.
Jeanne Mullich, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas, testified and voiced her concerns about S.B. 314. She hoped this committee would be able to help.
Sherrell Willey, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas, opposed S.B. 314 and expressed her opinions. It was her belief this bill would place a financial burden on many associations without giving the beneficial results desired. By requiring board members to attend continuing education, this would discourage home owners to volunteer their time and services. Most associations hire property management and legal advisors in order to help them govern effectively. Homeowner associations pay for those so their members of the board do not have to spend an excessive amount of time researching the best way to manage their community. The second objection was the monthly membership meetings. It was cost prohibitive to mail notices, most of the meetings were sparsely attended due to lack of interest not because they were not receiving notifications. The third point was to have a 5 percent reserve fund this would do a great disservice to the associations. Reserve contributions should be based on professional reserve studies dealing with the assets being considered. She felt this bill would do a big disservice to the home owners if it was passed as written.
Irene E. Porter, Lobbyist, Southern Nevada Home Builders Association, stated one of the things which had not been pointed out was a law governing units of common interest, there is a wide variety of associations and types of things that are going on. Part of the problem was this law was really for condominium projects. That seems to be where most of the complaints were coming from. There needed to be a great deal of regulation as to the association’s responsibility, such as the building, roofs, air-conditioning, common elements and there is a lot of complicated things. This law allowed people to get beyond the parameters of where they needed to be for all kinds of other instances. Most of the local governments are now requiring a landscape area on the outside of the perimeter of a standard single-family subdivision. The local governments are requiring the builder of that unit to put in a homeowners’ association to provide the long-term maintenance of the landscape strip which was required to benefit the community. The homeowners’ association takes on a life of its own and a lot of other issues that were not needed. In section 2 of chapter 116 of NRS, this was thought of in 1989, you could exempt from a lot of these provisions that kind of landscape association. There have not been any changes made since 1989 and the $500 a year may not cover the landscape now. She proposed the subcommittee take a look at chapter 116 of NRS, section 2, to make it relative to today’s needs relating to the homeowner associations which were there for just landscaping. There were about four levels of different types of homeowners’ associations that needed to be dealt with in the text of chapter 116 of NRS.
Senator Neal queried about a situation where an association would have a problem of land that was considered for public use. Then an eminent domain would not be any different than what would be exercised by the city, if that is correct.
Ms. Porter suggested this was something that needed to be looked at by the subcommittee and the legal staff of the Legislature in relation to homeowner associations. The homeowners’ associations should be able to work with the local government and if that is necessary for public use then it should be done in context with a government agency. She felt there was a need to break down within the law certain types of requirements for certain types of homeowners’ associations and also look at not allowing these boards to have the broad authority or governmental authority and bring them back to what they really should be doing. They needed to work as a unit with the owners to make their neighborhoods better rather than being governments.
Senator Schneider expressed the one thing that Ms. Porter said was the home builders in the fastest growing city in the nation are opting not to build associations because people will not buy in them. This will affect the property value of the associations.
Ms. Porter noted something that was needed to be looked at in this statute was to ensure that board of directors of homeowners’ associations cannot get into lawsuits without the people being informed, who ultimately have to pay the bill.
Senator Augustine asked if the city of Las Vegas and the county was taking over where some of the homeowner associations do not exist. There have been a lot of ordinances lately, building ordinances and zoning. Ms. Porter stated homeowner associations have been a way for government to get away from zoning ordinances and having to pay for certain maintenance. Government had encouraged the formation of homeowners’ associations because then government does not have to pay for the zoning ordinances, they can collect taxes for other things, and force homeowner associations to take care of all the ordinances.
Sharon Skroch, Concerned Citizen, Reno, stated she was opposed to S.B. 314, but she liked the amendments, and felt there needed to be some clarifications. She voiced her opinions on the problems of the education. She would like to see the frequency of meetings expanded and there should be meetings every month.
Senator Neal asked if Ms. Skroch had any thoughts on the "code of conduct." Ms. Skroch replied any person who understood what they were dealing with, so many number of units in an association or planned housing, understands that they cannot be self-serving. That is a code of conduct. In the statutes now it says that you can not be self-serving.
Vincent Ragazzo, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas, testified for S.B. 314 and voiced his concerns. He felt in his association the board ran his home and denied him any decision power over his home. When these condominium boards infringe upon the rights, we need the attorney general’s office to step in and say that was an infringement. We need help!
Dennis McGarvey, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas, stated he was the property manager for Lake Las Vegas, a community that would have over 6,000 units. He was opposed to S.B. 314 and stated he was concerned about the original bill, but the amendments addressed a lot of his concerns. His biggest problem was the added cost to each home owner in Nevada in a property association. The cost of one meeting a month would be very costly. The mandatory education for board members will be costly for the residents, and the board members would have to take their time to do this. The funding of the attorney general’s office by everybody will also be additional costs for association fees. He voiced his concerns regarding all the costs for these associations. He stated he was definitely against amendment 10 that required financial records to be made available to all residents.
Senator Neal questioned Mr. McGarvey what rights would a person have to give up to the association that would be held in common by the association. Mr. McGarvey stated he knew of no rights that would have to be given up. Senator Neal asked if he could improve his property if he wanted. Mr. McGarvey and Senator Neal held a discussion about what could and could not be done in a homeowner association with the owner’s property. Mr. McGarvey replied that the property itself was held in common, and improvements could be made if it maintained or helped the value of the property. Senator Neal asked what the association would prohibit after a home was purchased according to the plans. Mr. McGarvey stated if the exterior of the home was changed to devalue the property, according to the board of directors, this would be prohibited. A discussion ensued on things that could not be done in associations.
Eleissa C. Lavelle, Concerned Citizen, stated she was an attorney with the firm of Lavelle-Stubberud and Associates, and had been involved in the representation of individual home owners and their problems with boards of directors. She had also represented boards of directors in advising them the proper way to conduct business. She had consulted with property managers in the operations of their business. She was pleased to see the amendments the attorney general had proposed. A good reason for associations was to allow homeowners’ amenities and to live in neighborhoods that they could not otherwise afford. These associations have pools, parks, community functions, and clubhouses. There is a real purpose for these communities, and not all of them are run properly. Something needs to be done with these associations. She was concerned that the bill took too broad of an approach, we certainly encourage education of board members. There needs to be reserves and she supported reserve studies.
Senator Townsend asked Ms. Lavelle about her thoughts on standards of conduct. Ms. Lavelle stated she thought there should be a rule of good manners and good common sense, and she did not have a problem with that. The biggest problems were the people who were elected and refused to acknowledge what the rules were and abide by them. Whether or not a code of conduct for these people would be effective, she thought it was a step in the right direction.
Joan C. Wright, Lobbyist, Carriage House Timeshare and Silver Oak Development, stated she was representing time-share associations in Lake Tahoe and Las Vegas. She was opposed to the amendments that were presented, but the suggestions by the attorney general were helpful and would alleviate some concerns. Senator Neal asked how this would apply to time-share units. Ms. Wright stated because of the definition of a common-interest community this did include time-shares and that is the problem, especially with monthly meetings of the members. The legal structure of time-shares were equal to condominiums. The cost of monthly meetings would be cost prohibitive. She did see the concern about reserves, as an association could go bankrupt and the units not finished could be a disaster. She felt this should be not be under the control of the attorney general’s office, but it should be under the control of the Real Estate Division. Senator Schneider stated they were aware of the time-share problems and this would be discussed in the subcommittee meetings.
Jack Straus, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas, testified for S. B. 314 and voiced his concerns about liens on the homeowner associations’ property. A lot of problems that are dealt with daily had not been addressed and there needs to be more meetings to deal with those problems.
Gary Lein, Concerned Citizen, Las Vegas, opposed S. B. 314, stated he had seen a lot of positive things about the homeowners’ associations, but also had heard of a lot of horror stories about the associations. He stated the attorney general’s amendments would help with adjusting S.B. 314. Amendment 10 seemed to have a lot of generic information or requirements such as what was "good accounting practices". This is going to raise a lot of questions and a lot of time and effort needed to be put into the bill as to what the ramifications were going to be. He felt there needed to be a lot of time going line by line of the bill, getting the experience of the people, talking to the right people and get the information and do not pass this bill as a quick fix. It will create more problems in the long term.
The prepared remarks of Michael Buckley in opposition to S.B. 314 (Exhibit J), a letter from Judith A. Fenner, Old West Realty, stating objections to S.B. 314 (Exhibit K), and testimony of Gail Burks, Nevada Fair Housing Center, Inc. dated May 1, 1997 supporting S.B. 314 (Exhibit L) were presented to the committee, but no testimony was given on these exhibits.
Senator Townsend stated there would be a subcommittee meeting held and the recommendations would be brought back to the committee.
The hearing was adjourned at 11:20 a.m.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED:
Carolyn Hoganson,
Committee Secretary
APPROVED BY:
Senator Randolph J. Townsend, Chairman
DATE: