Assembly Bill No. 672–Committee on
Constitutional Amendments
March 22, 1999
____________
Referred to Committee on Constitutional Amendments
SUMMARY—Provides additional means to enforce Nevada’s claim to public lands. (BDR 26-1707)
FISCAL NOTE: Effect on Local Government: Yes.
Effect on the State or on Industrial Insurance: Yes.
~
EXPLANATION – Matter in
bolded italics is new; matter between brackets
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEVADA, REPRESENTED IN SENATE AND ASSEMBLY, DO ENACT AS FOLLOWS:
1-1
Section 1. Chapter 321 of NRS is hereby amended by adding thereto1-2
the provisions set forth as sections 2 and 3 of this act.1-3
Sec. 2. A person who performs an act with respect to the use,1-4
management or disposal of any of the public lands in this state, other1-5
than as an agent of this state, is guilty of a gross misdemeanor.1-6
Sec. 3. A person aggrieved by a violation of section 2 of this act may1-7
commence a civil action against the violator to recover damages suffered1-8
as a proximate result of the violation and is entitled to recover $20,000 or1-9
treble the amount of his actual damages, whichever is greater, plus his1-10
costs and reasonable attorney’s fees in the action.1-11
Sec. 4. NRS 321.596 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.596 The legislature finds that:1-13
1. The State of Nevada has a strong moral claim upon the public land1-14
retained by the Federal Government within Nevada’s borders because:1-15
(a) On October 31, 1864, the Territory of Nevada was admitted to1-16
statehood on the condition that it forever disclaim all right and title to1-17
unappropriated public land within its boundaries;2-1
(b) From 1850 to 1894, newly admitted states received 2 sections of2-2
each township for the benefit of common schools, which in Nevada2-3
amounted to 3.9 million acres;2-4
(c) In 1880 Nevada agreed to exchange its 3.9-million-acre school grant2-5
for 2 million acres of its own selection from public land in Nevada held by2-6
the Federal Government;2-7
(d) At the time the exchange was deemed necessary because of an2-8
immediate need for public school revenues and because the majority of the2-9
original federal land grant for common schools remained unsurveyed and2-10
unsold;2-11
(e) Unlike certain other states, such as New Mexico, Nevada received2-12
no land grants from the Federal Government when Nevada was a territory;2-13
(f) Nevada received no land grants for insane asylums, schools of2-14
mines, schools for the blind and deaf and dumb, normal schools, miners’2-15
hospitals or a governor’s residence as did states such as New Mexico; and2-16
(g) Nevada thus received the least amount of land, 2,572,478 acres, and2-17
the smallest percentage of its total area, 3.9 percent, of the land grant states2-18
in the Far West admitted after 1864, while states of comparable location2-19
and soil, namely Arizona, New Mexico and Utah, received approximately2-20
11 percent of their total area in federal land grants.2-21
2. The State of Nevada has a legal claim to the public land retained by2-22
the Federal Government within Nevada’s borders because:2-23
(a) In the case of the State of Alabama, a renunciation of any claim to2-24
unappropriated lands similar to that contained in the ordinance adopted by2-25
the Nevada constitutional convention was held by the Supreme Court of2-26
the United States to be "void and inoperative" because it denied to2-27
Alabama "an equal footing with the original states" in Pollard v. Hagan, 442-28
U.S. (3 How.) 212 (1845);2-29
(b) In Coyle v. Smith, 221 U.S. 559 (1911), the Supreme Court of the2-30
United States expressly affirmed the "equal footing" doctrine as2-31
enunciated in Pollard v. Hagan, 44 U.S. (3 How.) 212 (1845), holding2-32
that to ensure equality among the states, the legislature of the State of2-33
Oklahoma had the power to locate, change and appropriate money for its2-34
own seat of government and that the Congress of the United States could2-35
not, through the Enabling Act of June 16, 1906, ch. 335, 34 Stat. 267,2-36
require the State of Oklahoma to erect its seat of government in a2-37
location designated by Congress;2-38
(c) The State of Texas, when admitted to the Union in 1845, retained2-39
ownership of all unappropriated land within its borders, setting a further2-40
precedent which inured to the benefit of all states admitted later "on an2-41
equal footing"; and2-42
2-43
Constitution of the United States by the reference of Article VI to prior3-1
engagements of the Confederation, first proclaimed the "equal footing"3-2
doctrine, and the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, by which the territory3-3
including Nevada was acquired from Mexico and which is "the supreme3-4
law of the land" by virtue of Article VI, affirms it expressly as to the new3-5
states to be organized therein.3-6
3. The exercise of broader control by the State of Nevada over the3-7
public lands within its borders would be of great public benefit because:3-8
(a) Federal holdings in the State of Nevada constitute 86.7 percent of3-9
the area of the state, and in Esmeralda, Lincoln, Mineral, Nye and White3-10
Pine counties the Federal Government controls from 97 to 99 percent of3-11
the land;3-12
(b) Federal jurisdiction over the public domain is shared among 173-13
federal agencies or departments which adds to problems of proper3-14
management of land and disrupts the normal relationship between a state,3-15
its residents and its property;3-16
(c) None of the3-17
taxable and Federal Government activities are extensive and create a tax3-18
burden for the private property owners of Nevada who must meet the3-19
needs of children of Federal Government employees, as well as provide3-20
other public services;3-21
(d) Under general land laws only 2.1 percent of federal lands in Nevada3-22
have moved from federal control to private ownership;3-23
(e) Federal administration of the retained public lands, which are vital3-24
to the livestock and mining industries of the state and essential to meet the3-25
recreational and other various uses of its citizens, has been of uneven3-26
quality and sometimes arbitrary and capricious; and3-27
(f) Federal administration of the retained public lands has not been3-28
consistent with the public interest of the people of Nevada because the3-29
Federal Government has used those lands for armament and nuclear testing3-30
thereby rendering many parts of the land unusable and unsuited for other3-31
uses and endangering the public health and welfare.3-32
4. The intent of the framers of the Constitution of the United States3-33
was to guarantee to each of the states sovereignty over all matters within3-34
its boundaries except for those powers specifically granted to the United3-35
States as agent of the states.3-36
5. The attempted imposition upon the State of Nevada by the Congress3-37
of the United States of a requirement in the enabling act that Nevada3-38
"disclaim all right and title to the unappropriated public lands lying within3-39
said territory," as a condition precedent to acceptance of Nevada into the3-40
Union, was an act beyond the power of the Congress of the United States3-41
and is thus void.4-1
6. The purported right of ownership and control of the public lands4-2
within the State of Nevada by the United States is without foundation and4-3
violates the clear intent of the Constitution of the United States.4-4
7. The exercise of such dominion and control of the public lands4-5
within the State of Nevada by the United States works a severe, continuous4-6
and debilitating hardship upon the people of the State of Nevada.4-7
8. The State of Nevada, in enacting NRS 321.596 to 321.599,4-8
inclusive, as amended by this act, and sections 2 and 3 of this act, is4-9
acting as a sovereign state to enforce within its borders the provisions of4-10
the Constitution of the United States. In so acting, it is subject only to the4-11
original jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of the United States.4-12
Sec. 5. NRS 321.5963 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.5963 As used in NRS 321.596 to 321.599, inclusive, and sections4-14
2 and 3 of this act, unless the context otherwise requires:4-15
1. "Division" means the division of state lands of the state department4-16
of conservation and natural resources.4-17
2. "Public lands" means all lands within the exterior boundaries of the4-18
State of Nevada , including lands managed or controlled by the Bureau4-19
of Land Management, except lands:4-20
(a) To which title is held by any private person or entity;4-21
(b) To which title is held by the State of Nevada, any of its local4-22
governments or the University and Community College System of Nevada;4-23
(c) Which are located within congressionally authorized national parks,4-24
monuments, national forests or wildlife refuges or which are lands4-25
acquired by purchase consented to by the legislature;4-26
(d) Which are lawfully controlled by the United States Department of4-27
Defense, the Department of Energy or the Bureau of Reclamation; or4-28
(e) Which are held in trust for Indian purposes or are Indian4-29
reservations.4-30
Sec. 6. NRS 321.5967 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.59674-32
4-33
4-34
4-35
4-36
4-37
4-38
4-39
4-40
4-41
4-42
5-1
5-2
5-3
5-4
5-5
5-6
5-7
5-8
5-9
5-10
5-11
5-12
5-13
5-14
5-15
5-16
5-17
5-18
5-19
5-20
5-21
5-22
planning council, created pursuant to NRS 321.740:5-23
1. Shall review and approve or disapprove all regulations proposed by5-24
the state land registrar pursuant to NRS 321.597.5-25
5-26
pursuant to NRS 321.596 to 321.599, inclusive, if an appeal is taken5-27
pursuant to NRS 321.5987, and affirm, modify or reverse the decision.5-28
5-29
use of lands in Nevada under federal management which is submitted by5-30
the state land use planning agency.5-31
Sec. 7. NRS 321.597 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.597 1. The division shall hold the public lands of the state in5-33
trust for the benefit of the people of the state and shall manage them in an5-34
orderly and beneficial manner consistent with the public policy declared in5-35
NRS 321.5977.5-36
2.5-37
321.5973, the state land registrar may with the approval of the5-38
5-39
the public lands in an orderly and beneficial manner and to carry out the5-40
provisions of NRS 321.596 to 321.599, inclusive, and the public trust5-41
created in those sections.5-42
3. Except as otherwise provided in this subsection, the state land5-43
registrar may contract for or employ such professional and clerical6-1
personnel as are needed to carry out his functions. Any contract for6-2
professional services must be approved by the state board of examiners and6-3
any money necessary to compensate those persons must be approved for6-4
expenditure by the legislature or the interim finance committee.6-5
Sec. 8. NRS 321.5973 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.5973 1. Subject to existing rights6-7
lands in Nevada and all minerals not previously appropriated are the6-8
property of the State of Nevada and subject to its jurisdiction and control.6-9
2. Until equivalent measures are enacted by the State of Nevada, the6-10
rights and privileges of the people of the State of Nevada under the6-11
6-12
16 U.S.C. §§ 471a et seq., the General Mining Laws ,6-13
et seq.6-14
Raising Homestead Act, 43 U.S.C. § 299, the Taylor Grazing Act ,6-15
U.S.C. §§ 315 et seq. ,6-16
seq. ,6-17
Rangelands Improvement Act ,6-18
rights of way and easements for public utilities must be preserved under6-19
administration by the state.6-20
3. Public lands in Nevada which have been administered by the United6-21
States under international treaties or interstate compacts must continue to6-22
be administered by the state in conformance with those treaties or6-23
compacts.6-24
4. The board of county commissioners of each county:6-25
(a) May adopt such ordinances as are necessary to carry out the6-26
provisions of NRS 321.596 to 321.599, inclusive, concerning the public6-27
lands within the boundaries of the county; and6-28
(b) May by ordinance impose a fee for the use of public lands within6-29
the boundaries of the county as recommended by the land use planning6-30
council. The amount of the fee must be approved by the legislature if it is6-31
in session or the legislative commission if the legislature is not in session.6-32
The ordinance must not adversely affect any existing rights and6-33
privileges.6-34
5. As used in this section, "existing rights and privileges" means the6-35
rights and privileges which have been established and recognized by the6-36
laws, customs and judicial decisions of this state, including, but not6-37
limited to:6-38
(a) Rights of way for roads, trails, ditches, flumes, pipelines and6-39
utilities; and6-40
(b) Prospecting and mineral rights, grazing rights or privileges, the6-41
right to use land for recreational purposes, the right to harvest wild fruits6-42
free of charge and the rights of residents of this state to use wood, stone,7-1
gravel and clay free of charge if the wood, stone, gravel and clay is not7-2
sold commercially.7-3
Sec. 9. NRS 321.598 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.598 1. Except as otherwise provided in7-5
subsections 2 and 3, no sale, conveyance or other disposal of the public7-6
lands may be permitted or authorized by the state land registrar, unless7-7
specifically authorized by an act of the legislature enacted after July 1,7-8
1979.7-9
2. To the extent that the public lands may be conveyed, leased,7-10
permitted7-11
the state land registrar7-12
or permit the use of public lands to the same extent or in the same manner7-13
as those lands are conveyed, leased, licensed or permitted to be used by the7-14
Federal Government or any of its agencies.7-15
3. The board of county commissioners of a county in which public7-16
lands are located may, for any public purpose of the county or any city or7-17
town within the county, select any portion of the public lands located7-18
within the county that it wishes to acquire and notify the state land7-19
registrar in writing of its selection. Upon receipt of the notification, the7-20
state land registrar shall convey to the county all right, title and interest7-21
of the state in and to that portion of the public lands selected.7-22
4. All proceeds of fees, rents, royalties or other money paid to the state7-23
under NRS 321.596 to 321.599, inclusive, must be deposited with the state7-24
treasurer for credit to the state general fund.7-25
Sec. 10. NRS 321.5987 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.5987 1. Any person who is aggrieved by a decision of the state7-27
land registrar made pursuant to NRS 321.596 to 321.599, inclusive, may7-28
appeal by letter to the7-29
30 days after the date of the decision from which the appeal is taken. The7-30
letter must set out:7-31
(a) The decision from which the appeal is taken;7-32
(b) Legal grounds for the contention of the appellant that the decision7-33
exceeds the authority of the state land registrar; and7-34
(c) Facts to support the contention,7-35
with sufficient particularity to permit the state land registrar to prepare for7-36
a hearing.7-37
2. Upon receiving the letter, the7-38
(a) Dismiss the appeal if it appears from the letter to lack any merit; or7-39
(b) Set a date for a hearing of the appeal which must be not less than 157-40
days nor more than 45 days after the date on which the7-41
receives the letter. The7-42
and the appellant of the date, time and place of the hearing.7-43
3. Any hearing held by the8-1
4. The state land registrar or his representative shall present at the8-2
hearing the facts considered in reaching his decision. The appellant or his8-3
representative may present matters in support of his contention that the8-4
state land registrar’s decision exceeds his authority.8-5
5. If the appellant does not appear in person or by representative, the8-6
8-7
and may dismiss the appeal or take any other action which it finds to be8-8
reasonable and proper.8-9
6. The8-10
conducting the hearing. The order of the8-11
in a contested case.8-12
Sec. 11. NRS 321.599 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.599 The attorney general may initiate an action or defend8-14
an action commenced in any court to carry out or enforce the provisions of8-15
NRS 321.596 to 321.599, inclusive, or seek8-16
relief to protect the interests of the state or the people of the state in the8-17
public lands.8-18
8-19
attorney general refuses to initiate or defend such an action, the district8-20
attorney of the appropriate county may do so.8-21
Sec. 12. NRS 321.7355 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.7355 1. The state land use planning agency shall prepare, in8-23
cooperation with appropriate federal and state agencies and local8-24
governments throughout the state, plans or statements of policy concerning8-25
the acquisition and use of lands in the State of Nevada that are under8-26
federal management.8-27
2. The state land use planning agency shall, in preparing the plans and8-28
statements of policy, identify lands which are suitable for acquisition for:8-29
(a) Commercial, industrial or residential development;8-30
(b) The expansion of the property tax base, including the potential for8-31
an increase in revenue by the lease and sale of those lands; or8-32
(c) Accommodating increases in the population of this state.8-33
The plans or statements of policy must not include matters concerning8-34
zoning or the division of land and must be consistent with local plans and8-35
regulations concerning the use of private property.8-36
3. The state land use planning agency shall:8-37
(a) Encourage public comment upon the various matters treated in a8-38
proposed plan or statement of policy throughout its preparation and8-39
incorporate such comments into the proposed plan or statement of policy8-40
as are appropriate;8-41
(b) Submit its work on a plan or statement of policy periodically for8-42
review and comment by the land use planning8-43
advisory board on natural resources and any committees of the legislature9-1
or subcommittees of the legislative commission that deal with matters9-2
concerning the public lands;9-3
(c) On or before February 1 of each odd-numbered year, prepare and9-4
submit a written report to the legislature concerning any activities engaged9-5
in by the agency pursuant to the provisions of this section during the9-6
immediately preceding biennium, including, without limitation:9-7
(1) The progress and any results of its work; or9-8
(2) Any plans or statements of policy prepared pursuant to this9-9
section; and9-10
(d) Provide written responses to written comments received from a9-11
county or city upon the various matters treated in a proposed plan or9-12
statement of policy.9-13
4. Whenever the state land use planning agency prepares plans or9-14
statements of policy pursuant to subsection 1 and submits those plans or9-15
policy statements to the governor, legislature or an agency of the Federal9-16
Government, the state land use planning agency shall include with each9-17
plan or statement of policy the comments and recommendations of:9-18
(a) The land use planning9-19
(b) The advisory board on natural resources; and9-20
(c) Any committees of the legislature or subcommittees of the9-21
legislative commission that deal with matters concerning the public lands.9-22
5. A plan or statement of policy must be approved by the governing9-23
bodies of the county and cities affected by it before it is put into effect.9-24
Sec. 13. NRS 321.740 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.740 1. The land use planning9-26
17 members appointed by the9-27
of the several counties is hereby created.9-28
2. The9-29
shall appoint9-30
9-31
9-32
appointed must not be an elected officer.9-33
3. The members of the council shall elect a chairman from among9-34
their members on or before July 1 of each odd-numbered year. After the9-35
initial election, the chairman shall hold office for a term of 2 years9-36
commencing on July 1 of each odd-numbered year. If a vacancy occurs9-37
in the chairmanship, the members of the council shall elect a9-38
replacement for the remainder of the unexpired term.9-39
4. The council shall meet at such times and places as are specified by9-40
a call of the chairman. The affirmative vote of a majority of the members9-41
present at a meeting is sufficient to take any action of the council.10-1
5. The members of the council are entitled to receive a salary of not10-2
more than $80, as fixed by the council, for each day or portion of a day10-3
of attendance at a meeting of the council.10-4
6. While engaged in the business of the council, each member and10-5
any person employed by the council is entitled to receive the travel10-6
expenses and subsistence allowances10-7
10-8
employees generally.10-9
Sec. 14. NRS 321.750 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.750 The land use planning10-11
1. Advise the administrator on the development and distribution to10-12
cities and counties of information useful to land use planning.10-13
2. Advise the state land use planning agency regarding the10-14
development of plans and statements of policy pursuant to subsection 1 of10-15
NRS 321.7355.10-16
Sec. 15. NRS 321.755 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.755 1. The executive council of the land use planning10-18
council is hereby created to consider and make recommendations for land10-19
use planning in areas of critical environmental concern and to resolve10-20
inconsistencies between the land use plans of local government entities.10-21
2. The executive council consists of the administrator and four persons10-22
selected by the land use planning10-23
members. Each member of the executive council shall serve for 2-year10-24
terms.10-25
Sec. 16. NRS 321.761 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.761 1. If an inconsistency in land use plans develops between10-27
two or more adjacent or overlapping local government entities which10-28
cannot be resolved between them, one or more of them may request the10-29
state land use planning agency to study and assist in resolving the10-30
inconsistency.10-31
2. Upon receipt of such a request the administrator shall convene a10-32
meeting of all the affected entities and shall provide technical assistance10-33
and advice in resolving the inconsistency.10-34
3. If, after subsequent meetings over a reasonable period10-35
determined by the administrator, the affected entities cannot resolve the10-36
inconsistency, the matter10-37
of the land use planning10-38
Sec. 17. NRS 321.770 is hereby amended to read as follows: 321.770 1. The state land use planning agency shall provide10-40
assistance in land use planning for areas of critical environmental concern:10-41
(a) When the governor directs that the agency review and assist in land10-42
use planning for an area he finds to be of critical environmental concern.11-1
(b) When one or more local government entities request that the agency11-2
advise and assist in land use planning for an area which affects them and11-3
which they consider to be of critical environmental concern.11-4
2. Upon receipt of a directive or a request pursuant to subsection 1, the11-5
administrator shall study the problems of the area described and meet with11-6
the affected local government entities to receive their initial comments and11-7
recommendations. He shall then submit the matter of planning for the area11-8
of critical environmental concern to the executive council of the land use11-9
planning11-10
3. The executive council shall include in its procedures one or more11-11
public hearings upon notice given by at least one publication at least 2011-12
days before the hearing in a newspaper or combination of newspapers11-13
having general circulation throughout the area affected and each city and11-14
county any portion of whose territory lies within11-15
notice11-16
4. Following completion of the hearings and consideration of other11-17
information, the executive council shall make its final recommendations11-18
for land use planning policies in the area of critical environmental concern.11-19
The recommendations may include proposed land use regulations to carry11-20
out11-21
5. No land use regulation adopted by the executive council pursuant to11-22
this section may become effective without the approval of the governor.11-23
Sec. 18. NRS 328.500 is hereby amended to read as follows: 328.500 1. The legislature finds that more than 87 percent of the11-25
land in the State of Nevada is held by the Federal Government, of which11-26
69 percent is public land, and the actions of federal agencies and11-27
instrumentalities involving the public lands and waters appurtenant to and11-28
public roads over those lands significantly affect the health, safety, welfare11-29
and happiness of the citizens of this state and may interfere with the11-30
traditional sovereign functions of the State of Nevada with respect to those11-31
lands, waters and roads and their uses.11-32
2. Except as otherwise provided in subsection 3, the attorney general11-33
may:11-34
(a) On his own initiative or at the request of the governor or any state11-35
agency, bring and maintain any action; or11-36
(b) Intervene on behalf of or bring and maintain an action on the11-37
relation of, any person in any meritorious case,11-38
in any court or before any federal agency if any action or proposed action11-39
by a federal agency or instrumentality with respect to the public lands or11-40
waters appurtenant to or public roads over those lands impairs or tends to11-41
impair the sovereignty of the State of Nevada.11-42
3. The attorney general may bring an action pursuant to this section if:12-1
(a) The legislature has appropriated sufficient money for the operation12-2
of his office to permit him to bring and maintain the action until its12-3
conclusion; or12-4
(b) He has obtained the permission:12-5
(1) From the legislature, if it is in session, expressed by a concurrent12-6
resolution; or12-7
(2) If the legislature is not in session, from the interim finance12-8
committee.12-9
4. As used in this section, "public lands" means all lands within the12-10
exterior boundaries of the State of Nevada , including lands managed or12-11
controlled by the Bureau of Land Management, except lands:12-12
(a) To which title is held by any private person or entity;12-13
(b) To which title is held by the State of Nevada, any of its local12-14
governments or the University and Community College System of Nevada;12-15
(c) Which are located within congressionally authorized national parks,12-16
monuments, national forests or wildlife refuges or which are lands12-17
acquired by purchase consented to by the legislature;12-18
(d) Which are lawfully controlled by the United States Department of12-19
Defense, the Department of Energy or the Bureau of Reclamation; or12-20
(e) Which are held in trust for Indian purposes or are Indian12-21
reservations.12-22
Sec. 19. The amendatory provisions of section 2 of this act do not12-23
apply to offenses that were committed before the effective date of this act.12-24
Sec. 20. This act becomes effective upon passage and approval.~